Is your employment contract enforceable?
We’ve written before on the importance of termination clauses in employment contracts. A recent case from the Ontario Superior Court of Justice is a good example of not only including a termination clause in an employment contract, but ensuring that it abides by minimum standards set out by the law.
Carpenter v Brains II, Canada Inc.
The Facts
Between 1996 and 2007, Ms. Carpenter worked at a company that was eventually sold to Brains II. In 2007, Brains II extended a written employment contract to Ms. Carpenter, which she accepted. Ms. Carpenter worked at Brains II until May 28, 2014, when she received notice that her employment would terminate effective July 23, 2014. She received eight weeks’ working notice and 18 weeks’ severance pay in accordance with the Employment Standards Act.
Ms. Carpenter commenced a wrongful dismissal action seeking damages for the income she lost. Brains II argued that her employment contract precluded her from claiming extra damages. The contract stipulated that Brains II would provide notice or salary in lieu thereof and severance pay under the ESA, and that she was not entitled to any other compensation by reason of the termination. Ms. Carpenter argued that the termination clause was unenforceable as it did not mention benefit continuance during the notice period, which does not comply with the ESA.
The Decision
The court found that the termination clause provided the employee with less than her minimum statutory entitlements and was therefore null and void. Due to the way the contract was drafted, the fact that the termination clause provided for salary in lieu of notice and made no mention of benefit continuance lent itself to the interpretation that the employer was attempting to limit the employee’s entitlements upon termination in contradiction with the ESA. Therefore, Ms. Carpenter was entitled to extra damages.
Lessons to be learned
- It is a good idea to require new employees to sign an employment contract with a termination clause.
- Even if the employment contract includes a termination clause, it may be unenforceable if it is not drafted properly.
- You should consult with a lawyer that is familiar with the nuances of drafting and employment law to ensure your employment contract is valid and enforceable.
The material and information in this blog and this website are for general information only. They should not be relied on as legal advice or opinion. The authors make no claims, promises, or guarantees about the accuracy, completeness, or adequacy of any information referred to in this blog or its links. No person should act or refrain from acting in reliance on any information found on this website or blog. Readers should obtain appropriate professional advice from a lawyer duly licensed in the relevant jurisdiction. These materials do not create a lawyer-client relationship between you and any of the authors or the MacLeod Law Firm.
Tags: Barrie Employment Lawyer Departing Employees Doing Business In Ontario Employee Termination Employee Terminations Employment Contract Employment Lawyers Barrie Employment Lawyers Toronto Employment Standards Employment Standards Act Ontario Employment Legislation Reasonable Notice Of Resignation Termination Clause Toronto Employment Lawyer Wrongful Dismissal
Recent Posts
Wrongful Dismissal: How To Reduce Litigation Risk
The best way to reduce litigation risk in relation to an employee termination is to agree in advance how much notice of termination (or pay in lieu of notice) an employee is entitled to receive. Employers rarely provide ANY notice of termination so the employee’s...
Mandatory COVID Vaccination Policies
Like most employment lawyers, I have been getting calls from employers asking whether they can require employees to get vaccinated for COVID before returning to the workplace.
The end of IDEL ( i.e. COVID layoffs) under the Employment Standard Act: The Great Reckoning
Some employers have benefitted from COVID and others have not. The federal government has supported the “have not” employers with a 75% wage subsidy. But it is scheduled to come to an end in September. So I have been getting calls from employers who cannot maintain...