As employees, we expect that our compensation will continue increase with our length of service. However, sometimes that’s not always the case. An employer may be experiencing financial difficulties and in an effort to cut costs, it asks its employees to take a pay cut. On the other hand, an employer could be quite profitable, but may make changes to a compensation plan as a motivational tool.
If this is happening to you, we know you’re thinking: “is my employer allowed to do this”?
It depends. Some changes to your compensation could constitute constructive dismissal. Constructive dismissal occurs when the employer imposes a unilateral change to your terms of employment that is fundamental and substantial.
Reduction in Salary
A reduction in salary needs to be significant in order to be considered constructive dismissal. Courts have generally said that less than 10% is not significant and over 20% is usually significant. In between, there is grey area and whether the salary reduction constitutes constructive dismissal will depend on whether other changes have occurred. Other changes that the Court will look at include: demotion, change in job duties, change in reporting structure, change in benefits, loss of job perks (ex. company car).
Change in Remuneration Structure
Changes to how an employee is compensated have at times been held to be constructive dismissal. For example, if an employee is changed from straight commission to straight salary or vice versa. However, modifications to how commission is calculated may or may not be acceptable. Certainly if changes are contemplated in an employment contract then the Court is generally more likely to find the changes are acceptable. The Court will also consider if the change would actually result in a reduction in earnings.
Changes to Benefits and Bonuses
Similarly, a change in benefits or bonuses may be a constructive dismissal if it amounts to a significant change. As discussed above, a change that results in a reduction in remuneration of less than 10% is unlikely to be significant enough to be considered constructive dismissal.
Each case is fact specific and the reality is that proving constructive dismissal is no easy task. It is important that an employee object to the change promptly. If you think that your employer is making changes to your compensation that could be a constructive dismissal, we would be happy to discuss your concerns with you. You should keep in mind that even if you have been constructively dismissed, you may be obligated to accept the pay reduction and continue working while you look for a new job. To speak with one of our lawyers who has expertise in this area, please contact us at [email protected] or 647-204-8107.
The Employment Standards Act the (“ESA”) contains a provision which allows for temporary lay-off. Pre Covid-19, the ESA told employers that they could lay off an employee for 13 out of 20 weeks, or 35 out of 52 weeks if the employer continues the employee’s benefits, for example.
As we have written before, termination clauses may have a significant effect on how much money you receive if you are terminated. If you are fired because of a business decision and not misconduct, it is the without cause termination clause that determines how much...
With the numbers of COVID-19 cases rising again, especially in the GTA, many employees are asking me as a Toronto employment lawyer what happens if they become sick and they are forced to stay home for 14 days. Following the end of the Canada Emergency Response...