Can an Employee Stop an Employer from Hiring a Job Applicant?

by | Mar 25, 2019 | For Employees

In a recent case, a female employee asked her employer not to hire a male executive because he had sexually harassed her when he had been employed earlier. The employer refused, the employee quit, and claimed, among other things, wrongful dismissal damages and punitive damages.

This case deals with the conflict between an employer’s right to hire whomever it wishes and its obligation to provide a safe and discrimination free workplace.

The Facts

In 1995, Mr. Benoit sexually harassed Ms. Colistro who reported to him as well as other employees. This misconduct was one of the reasons he was terminated without just cause.

In 2007, Ms. Colistro found out the Company intended to rehire Mr. Benoit and she immediately told the hiring manager about the earlier sexual harassment and asked that Mr. Benoit not be re-hired. The hiring manager sent Ms. Colistro a letter that stated, “there is no legal or other reason to not go forward with hiring Mr. Benoit.”

Three days later, Ms. Colistro told the hiring manager that she was “not eating or sleeping, was vomiting and on the verge of a nervous breakdown.” She saw her doctor, who provided a note advising that she would be off work due to stress. The Company offered to accommodate Ms. Colistro by transferring her to an equivalent position in an adjacent building. But she would accept nothing less than the Company not proceeding with the hiring of Mr. Benoit.

Ms. Colistro resigned her employment claiming she was constructively dismissed because continued employment would be intolerable.

Constructive Dismissal Claim

The trial judge concluded Ms. Colistro was constructively dismissed because, among other things, the letter which stated “there is no legal or other reason to not go forward with hiring Mr. Benoit” was demeaning, dismissive and “re-victimized the plaintiff and minimized the past conduct of Mr. Benoit in the eyes of the plaintiff and other (Company) employees.”. He awarded her damages based on a 12-month notice period. The Ontario Court of Appeal (the “OCA”)  upheld these damages.

Punitive Damages

The trial judge  found that the Company’s conduct toward Ms. Colistro was flagrant and outrageous and ordered it to pay her $ 100,000 in punitive damages. In doing so, he found the treatment of Ms. Colistro to be grossly unfair, unduly insensitive, and in blatant disregard of her interests. The judge also referenced the extensive expert medical evidence which established that Ms. Colistro “suffered actual damages as a direct result of the way in which she was treated by the Company at the time of her dismissal.” The OCA also upheld these damages.

Legal Costs

Even though the trial judge awarded Ms. Colistro constructive dismissal damages and punitive damages, he ordered Ms. Colistro to pay costs to the Company in the amount of $150,000 and to the City of Thunder Bay in the amount of $50,000. The OCA upheld this cost order. So even though  Ms. Colistro “won” this case, it cost her money to do so.

Lessons to be Learned:

  1. An employer has an obligation to provide a safe and healthy workplace that is discrimination free. If an employee claims to feel unsafe, then carefully listen to the employee and seriously consider these concerns.
  2. When dealing with a vulnerable employee take the high road if at all possible. This will reduce or eliminate the risk of a punitive damages award.
  3. Always consider making a formal offer to settle under the Rules of Civil Procedure. An employee thereafter takes an unreasonable settlement position at their peril.

For 30 years, Doug MacLeod of the MacLeod Law Firm has been advising employers on all aspects of the employment relationship. If you have any questions, you can contact him at 416 317-9894 or at [email protected]

The material and information in this blog and this website are for general information only. They should not be relied on as legal advice or opinion. The authors make no claims, promises, or guarantees about the accuracy, completeness, or adequacy of any information referred to in this blog or its links. No person should act or refrain from acting in reliance on any information found on this website or blog. Readers should obtain appropriate professional advice from a lawyer duly licensed in the relevant jurisdiction. These materials do not create a lawyer-client relationship between you and any of the authors or the MacLeod Law Firm.



Recent Posts


Recent Posts

Justice for Unionized Employees

Unionized employees often seek our advice regarding human rights issues in their workplace. Sometimes this is because human rights violations have occurred and the union is not assisting them. Other times, the union itself may be part of the problem. The rights of...

read more

Toronto Office

702 - 2 Bloor Street West,
Toronto, ON M4W 3E2

Barrie Office

277 - 92 Caplan Avenue,
Barrie, ON L4N 9J2

Collingwood Office

220 - 1 First Street
Collingwood, ON
L9Y 1A1



+1 (888) 640-1728


(866) 883-8445


[email protected]

Toronto Office

729 - 2 Bloor Street West, Toronto ON M4W 3E2

Barrie Office

277 - 92 Caplan Avenue, Barrie ON L4N 9J2

Collingwood Office

220 - 1 First Street, Collingwood, ON L9Y 1A1


Subscribe To Our Newsletter

Join our mailing list to receive the latest news and updates from our team.

You have Successfully Subscribed!