Are Repeated Compliments Sexual Harassment?
Despite increased media attention to the issue, sexual harassment and sexual assault continue to occur in the workplace.
In a recent decision, the Human Rights Tribunal of Ontario addressed the problem of unwanted compliments and touching in a real estate brokerage.
The Case
In Panucci v. Seller’s Choice Stockdale Realty Ltd., the applicant was a self-employed commission salesperson who worked under the supervision of a broker at Stockdale Realty.
The applicant told the Tribunal that the broker, Ronald Stockdale, had persistently complimented her appearance, invited her to drink wine with him, requested hugs for assisting her with work, and caressed her shoulder on one occasion.
While Mr. Stockdale denied the allegations, the Tribunal found that the applicant’s evidence was credible and that even if he was not directly told by the applicant to cease his conduct, he ought to have known that it was unwelcome.
The Tribunal awarded the applicant $15,000 in general damages for injury to her dignity and self-respect.
Lessons from the Case
Significantly, the Tribunal reiterated the principle that human rights legislation may apply to self-employed persons or independent contractors. Even though the applicant was not an employee of Stockdale Realty, there was a breach of the Human Rights Code.
This case further highlights the importance for individuals experiencing stress or other health issues as a result of harassment to seek medical assistance. This may become evidence in a later claim. The Tribunal commented that while the applicant described her health concerns, she presented no evidence about the medical impact of the sexual harassment. Had she done so, the damage award may have been higher.
Finally, the case is important as it further reiterates that there is a power imbalance between supervisors and employees and that employees may not feel able to confront a supervisor engaging in unwanted comments or touching. The fact that the individual does not say no or complain about the behaviour is not sufficient reason to conclude the conduct did not occur or was welcome.
If you would like to speak with an experienced lawyer about sexual harassment or other human rights issues, please contact us at [email protected] or 647-204-8107.
Recent Posts
Different Company, Same Old Job: What happens when the company you work for is sold?
Are clauses that purport to waive an employee’s years of service for the purposes of severance/notice pay enforceable? It’s all important when your company is sold. Here is what to look for.
read moreFailure to Address Workplace Harassment Results in Aggravated Damages
As we have written before, an employer may generally terminate an employee for any good business reason, as long as it provides the employee with adequate notice of termination (or pay in lieu of notice). Failure to provide adequate notice results in a wrongful...
read moreWhat is Employment Insurance Anyway? A Primer on EI
If you have lost your job and need temporary income support, do you know what to do? In Canada, you can apply for Employment Insurance (“EI”) for partial income replacement from the Federal government. To learn about the different types of EI and whether you would be...
read more