Did you know that an employer is generally required to maintain an employee’s benefits until the end of the minimum notice period provided for under the Employment Standards Act (ESA) whether or not the employer provides the employee with actual notice of termination.
Is the employer also required to continue benefit plan contributions throughout the common law “reasonable notice period” which is almost always longer than the ESA notice period? Ontario’s Court of Appeal recently answered this question.
Brito v. Canac Kitchens : The Facts
Canac Kitchen terminated Mr. Brito’s employment after 24 years service. Within two weeks, Mr. Brito, 55 years old, found another job however his new employer did not provide short-term or long-term disability benefits. About 1 ½ years later, Mr. Brito was diagnosed with cancer which resulted in surgery, chemotherapy and a total disability.
Mr. Brito claimed that Canac should have continued his long-term disability coverage throughout the common law reasonable notice period. The trial judge agreed. He found that Mr. Brito should have received 22 months notice of termination and because the total disability took place during the reasonable notice period he was entitled to receive, among other damages, an amount equal to the LTD benefits he would have received from the date he became totally disabled within the meaning of Canac’s LTD policy until he turned 65 years old.
Lessons To Be Learned
1. An employer’s obligation to continue benefits for a terminated employee is not limited to the minimum notice period under the Employment Standards Act.
2. Most LTD plans do not allow an employer to continue LTD coverage for a terminated employee beyond the ESA minimum notice period. The chance of a person becoming totally disabled may be small however the employer’s potential legal exposure is usually HUGE.
3. Reaching an early settlement with a terminated employee where the person agrees to release the employer from this kind of damage claim as a term of settlement is one way to limit the legal exposure associated with this kind of claim.
If you have any questions about an employer’s obligations to a terminated employee, please call us at 1–888-640-1728 or email us at [email protected]
The issue of whether a termination clause limits an employee’s entitlement to the minimum notice set out in the Employment Standards Act may be the most litigated issue in employment law over the past 5 years.
We have started the last month of 2019 and it is time for my annual top Employment Law stories of the year. 2019 has been a relatively good news year for Ontario employers. On January 1, 2019, the new Conservative provincial government started the year by delaying...
When speaking with a client about other terms of employment that can be included in an employment contract, I always ask whether the organization has an Employee Handbook.