Was your Suspension a Constructive Dismissal?
Employees today spend as much time at work as they do at home. So, the workplace should be an environment where you feel secure, trusted and safe. Unexpected changes in your job, such as a suspension, can leave you feeling confused, frustrated and unsure of where you stand. Your employer has a duty to abide to the contract, policies and/or handbook that you have signed. A suspension without pay may be a constructive dismissal unless you have agreed to this kind of discipline in an employment contract or policy. This was recently highlighted by the Court of Appeal in Filice v. Complex Services Inc.
To learn other workplace changes which might be a constructive dismissal see here.
Mr. Filce worked for a casino run by Complex Service Inc. as a Security Shift Supervisor. The Alcohol and Gaming Commission of Ontario audited the casino and discovered inconsistencies in entries made by Mr. Flice. Mr. Filce was then investigated by police and Complex placed him on an unpaid suspension.
Mr. Filce’s suspension lasted 17 months. During this time he was charged with theft, but never convicted. However, because he lost his gaming license, after the unpaid suspension, Complex terminated Mr. Flice’s employment.
Mr. Flice sued for constructive dismissal arguing that Complex had no right to suspend him without pay. The Superior agreed and awarded him pay for the 17 months he missed during the suspension and $100,000 in punitive damages.
Complex appealed. However, the Court of Appeal agreed that Complex did not have the right to suspend Mr. Filce without pay in his employment contract or handbook. Doing so, was a constructive dismissal. However, the Court of Appeal did reduce his damages.
Lessons For Employees
- Read and understand your employment contract and employment policies or handbooks. These policies can take away your rights, or give your employer rights such as the ability to suspend you without pay.
- If you are suspended, get legal advice. Your employer may not be allowed to do so, and you pay be able to get compensation or get back to work sooner.
If you have questions about suspensions or constructive dismissal and would like more information, you can contact an employment lawyer at MacLeod Law Firm. You can reach us at [email protected] or 647-204-8107.
As we’ve written before, when an employee is terminated and offered a severance package, they are almost always asked to sign a release agreement in exchange. A release agreement, as the name suggests, releases the employer from liabilities for employment-related...read more
If you are totally disabled and collecting disability benefits from a LTD insurer, did you know that your employer may also owe you up to 34 weeks termination & severance pay? How can this be you may ask? Well, the short answer is there is a provision in a...read more
We have been advising Ontario employees for 30 years. We only practice workplace law so “All We Do Is WORK!” We have experience assisting employees from all walks of life. From people in entry level positions to senior executives in the private and public sectors. We...read more